I was a watcher and a listener as a kid. Not birds, not zoo animals, not after you sharpen your pencils sit back down in your seat and put your head down, although I was good at that too. I behaved, always, but that wasn’t the goal. I behaved as a means to an end. I behaved to observe. I was a watcher and a listener, a small, secret sentry.
They watched and smiled indulgently when I drew an imaginary friend and ABCs on my pale peach wall, when I posed in stone archways of churches and in the Dunkin Donuts with bright camera lights melting a chocolate donut that I did not want—such a little actress!
At home, they watched and smiled appreciatively when I asked them over and over, What do you want me to be now? This was my favorite game and their favorite game. I could watch them while they watched me. What do you want me to be? A penguin? A princess? A pony? Tell me what to be. Tell me what to be. Tell me what to be.
I liked that I could give them this. I was good at this.
Kids didn’t much interest me. I was insufferable in their presence—look what I can do! it’s something you can only do if you know how to ride a two-wheeler!—or stilted and anxious. Our neighborhood was virtually barren of kids then, and except for my younger brother, who made some sense to me (and still does), I had not learned to understand people my size or take them seriously.
I honed in on adults. They were the ones who concerned me. They worried me deeply, these tall people with their odd, painful ways. I watched them carefully for what easily went unseen by people twice my size. I listened for what went unheard by people twice my size. I scanned. I scouted. I stood vigil. I gathered information that I had no place for, information I didn’t want to keep and hoped that someone twice my size would have some use for.
Sometimes I offered it up to them—bravely, I think now, then dismiss that thought, embarrassed—small palms open, dark round eyes worried. But they had no place to put it either, so they pressed it back into my hands, closed my fingers back over my offering, and sent me on my way.
They did the best they knew how, and they didn’t. As we all do, and don’t. I understood it then, as I understand it now. It is the part of me that has changed the least over the years. Everyone is just doing the best they can. You can’t be mad at someone for doing their best. What could be more unkind than being mad at someone for doing their best?
I am still a watcher and a listener. Being an adult now, or some facsimile thereof, I have honed in on myself, as well as the now-my-size people. I am wary of both. I tend to keep my palms closed. No fists in public—nothing unfriendly, nothing you would notice. I am unfailingly friendly in my necessary travels, friendly to a fault (but do your best and no one is to blame, so let’s skip over the fault, jackrabbit right over it, jump). I still behave, as a means to an end. But really, I am watching and listening to you.
And to me. These days, I spend far more time watching myself and listening to myself than I do you, so you don’t have much to worry about anymore. If you do find yourself in one of my stories or plays someday, or in the poems that will surely—and awkwardly, as dumb as cattle—come, you can trust me to paint you in your best light. Unless I caught you being mean, unless you were cruel to me along the way. Even then, you’d have a fighting chance of coming across as simply conflicted, hurt at an early age, wounded by women, mishandled by men, disturbed, sick, anything but mean. So relax.
I can see you are trying hard, and that touches me. Effort goes a long way in my book. You’re appreciated here. I won’t get mad. I don’t do mad, not real mad, at least. I go directly to sad—Do Not Pass Go, Do Not Collect the Satisfaction of a Good Loud Fight that Clears the Air.
I’m good at sad. These days, I am very good at sad. And I worry that I am not doing my best at undoing sad. Because I have these people, see. Half my size. Two of them. And they see more than my wide hips and the soft belly they tell me they remember living in. They look up. They watch. They listen. They watch and listen when I am too busy watching and listening to myself to notice.
These days, my two favorite half-my-size people come to me with palms open, touching my cheeks, searching my face to figure out why I am crying, again. Sometimes, they watch helplessly as I cry with hands balled up in fists. It hits me—too late, after the fact, long after they have been ushered off to bed by people twice their size, people who are not crying again and again and again like Mommy—there’s not much room in a fist for a small open hand.
Some of you come here for the funny, for the show pony, for the poo, and I am glad I can give that to you. I am surprised that I can give that to you, even now. Tell me what to be. The comments flood in, and I feel good. Laughter! To make a stranger laugh! To wring a laugh from poo, from parenting, in the form of small dashes and dots on a lit screen! Doing my best! Doing something right!
I do like to write. I am good at it, sometimes. I would like very much to think of myself as a funny writer-person, a likeable, memorable something or other of a person. But I trust myself more on the page or the computer screen than I do in person. I can be careful when I type—less so when I talk, too easy to get sloppy—and it surprises me when people ask how I can reveal so much on the blog. It is hard to know what is authentic. I want to be authentic, I want to believe it is all me, all real, so I can hand it all over to my daughters when it is time and simply exhale, knowing I have done my best, done good, done me well enough for them to carry me with them in a way that does not hurt them. I want them to be able to travel lightly.
Some of you will pull back, will not comment on this post. Yes, it’s true, I will notice. It will worry me. It will. It will bounce me more quickly back to poo than if you had commented, and some of you will be relieved to get back to the poo. I understand. I am wishing my life were plain poo, too.
Poo is simple. Parenting when you’re very, very, very sad is not so simple. No one talks much of this. I have not heard what I need to hear, what I am waiting to hear. I keep watching. I keep listening. I wonder why what is wrong with me is not wrong with you.
Sometimes I think we are entering a new 1950s, a new psychotropic-cocktails-at-the-door, How was your day, dear? era, and I feel the panic surge again, the panic that makes me swing hard to the left, to the right, to get away from tiny talk, the small small talk that makes me dash behind closed doors and cringe at the ringing phone.
My family is not getting the funny. Their comments don’t look or sound like yours. I have yet to come across an emoticon my household of one same-size person and two half-my-size persons could make any use of.
This is such a long post, I am hoping that those who come here only for the laughs have already abandoned ship, way back when, somewhere around paragraph three or four. I press on for a reason. I do. And trust me, it’s hard to press on, because the voice in my head is a bossyboots dominatrix who likes to hiss self-indulgent! who cares? wrap it up! too late for you, show pony! and rap me on the wrist with a miniature bullwhip.
Perhaps there are only nine or ten of you left out there reading this. I think I know who you are, even if I wouldn’t recognize some of you on the street. I guess I am talking to you, if you don’t mind me talking to you like this. I know I am saying more than I usually do, but I am wary and ready to jackrabbit out of this mess of language if the last nine or ten of you aren’t having any of it either. I can make you forget it ever happened, if necessary.
But I’m trying hard to do my best here. And I think part of doing my best, so I can let myself off the hook, is working harder at keeping my palms open. For my little half-my-size ones, and for anyone else who’s looking for a pair of open palms.
Nothing scares me but myself these days. So if you are sad, I want to tell you that you are safe here. You’re in good company. If you have scouted and scanned and sought and still have come up empty-handed, well, look, we don’t have to touch or anything. We can just shrug helplessly at each other, right here in this small dark space, and show each other our palms. Nothing to hide—at least, nothing that can fit in an open hand, or a blog.

{ 5 trackbacks }
{ 177 comments… read them below or add one }
← Previous Comments
At least 151 people care enough to keep going through the sad. That’s not too shabby.
Sometimes people are sad. And what I remember from Creative Writing 101 is Write What You Know. You are a beautiful writer.
oh, Jenn. So many stunning images in this post. I read every word and am sitting here trying not to cry too loudly in my cubicle. Write. Write whatever words are pushing their way out of you. I need to tell you that reading this just gave me permission to continue with it, my own writing, my own looking inward. I’ve felt such a disconnect over the past year and so unable to put it in words. Like an inpenetrable fog inside of me. I’ve been riding the tiny waves on the surface instead of letting myself sink into the cold deep parts and it’s making me so unhappy. So sad. Thank you. Peace out, sister–palms outstretched.
The last paragraph made me cry. I am broken right now, but I will show you my palms.
I’ve been struggling through the sad for so long that I don’t remember what it’s like to not be sad. My half-my-size people worry about me, too, and I hope that I’m not damaging them. I’m trying really hard to be “better”. Here are my palms, here’s my shrug; thanks for the space.
I’ve tried to write this comment at least a hundred times. I don’t know how to put into words how deeply this post touched me. Without taking away from your rawness, your saddness, I feel somehow comforted. It’s dark out there, lately and it sometimes I think I’ve been shut away from the whole world. Thank you for your openness — it’s a ray of hope in this desolate winter. Open palms… an image I won’t soon forget.
Actually I always come for your writing, not the subject. You could write about telephone books and rain gauges or a funeral and make it beautiful and profound and funny all at once. Writing is one of the things I can see that you do extraordinarily well. I don’t know how many others you do well. I wouldn’t presume to know. I just know that sometimes a body gets the blues and like everything else, it will pass. Sometimes it DOES feel like life is an ongoing identity crisis. But with writing like this, damn! Lady, you got chops. Never doubt that. And never doubt that the same creativity goes straight into raising your kids. Someday they will have the blues, and they will find a way to alchemize it into some kind of art. Just you wait and see.
I’m struggling with words. I feel shaky inside. Being the 157th post, I don’t know if there is a point to posting a comment – but your post was powerful and it touched me. I feel shaky because once upon a time I was one of those half-size people wondering why mommy was crying. Like then, my instinct is to mobilize into fix it mode. But I learned, much to my disappointment, there is really nothing I could/can do. And so I sit here feeling paralyzed.
I will keep reading in the hopes that this sad train you are on turns into a less sad train. I hope, hope, hope…
Jen,
I wonder if you’ve considered therapy? It might really help.
A
I am sad, too, sad the way you burst into tears when you hear a song on the radio. Sad for days before and days that I will never have. Sad for days I passed up in favor of comfort and thus am now uncomfortable.
I am sorry, Jen, and I hear you. I hear your real voice. You don’t have to be funny for me.
Peace, friend.
Jen my sweet girl. I read you every day whether I comment or not. I read you for the substance which IS you. Poo or no Poo. Sure you entertain me but more often you make me stop and think about my own life. I didn’t read what everyone else wrote first because I just wanted to write how I feel without knowing what anyone else had written.
I feel your pain. I suffer from depression. You have my email. My palms are open sweetie.
I hope sad passes soon. I really do. Not because I want funny posts. Just because I’ve been sad and anxious, too.
I understand this dark place all too well also Jenn, and it can be so overpowering for me as well. Like No. 41, Jennifer, panic is a big issue for me also. When one of my girls is really sick, I panic and want to run to the dr. and fearful if I don’t, what if something bad happens? In a world where moms are suppose to show a positive, nurturing, always happy persona, that is an impossibility all the time. As women, we are wired differently, and I believe that has a good purpose, but sometimes it is hard to see past the teary eyes and the haze that shadows our happiness at certain times. Know by all of these posts, you are never alone, and like another poster said, that she would love to be your friend, and sit with you coffee in hand and talk, same with me Jenn. You give me so much through your blog, and I know I’m not the only one that could affirm that to you. From one tight fisted at times mom to another, I will work to keep my palms open for little hands more than I do. Thank you for the reminder and for the courage it took to post this, you are a helluva woman!
You have a beautiful heart, Jenn…I wish I could give you a hug and make tea and help the sadness fade, even for just a little while.
Jenn, I know this sad too. The 3 or 4 people who read my blog can attest to that – though I do not have quite the talent you do for putting words together. You are gifted writer, whatever your topic and as you can see there are an awful lot of us who think so. I am a lurker and (very infrequent) commenter and I will read your blog regardless of the subject. I hope you are feeling better soon.
I’m sad too, but can’t even muster the funny. There was some poo at my house this morning, but I wasn’t home for it. It was cat poo. And my boyfriend cleaned it up. He’ll pick up cat poo in a plastic bag off the floor, but he isn’t ready to marry me.
Jenn, I love every post you write. The funny is great, but the sad also strikes a chord in me too. I lurk here too often without commenting, but I want you to know that all of us who read here send you love and hugs and long talks over coffee, because even though we may not know you in the friend-next-door way, your writing brings you to us in a much more real and tangible fashion. We hope for you a less sad time, but we sit with you in your sadness in spirit even so. *hugs*
I was JUST blogging about this – well, not so courageously, but still. I’m glad Rachel the velveteen rabbi referred me to your blog.
I feel so unecessary…weighed down by the flood of comments you’ve already received. But if one more stranger telling you that they read through that long heart wrenching post might help in any way, who I am to withold that?
I have no reason to write this, no other purpose or plan to serve. I don’t know, and you don’t know me. I have no reason to flatter you.
I’ve read a little here and there, been intimidated by how many people come here to praise you, and found myself wandering away. But I wandered back because you write beautifully. I don’t toss that compliment out lightly. I mean “beautifully.”
Hi Jenn,
I have only recently begun to read your penetrating and beautiful posts…just stumbled upon them, and I’m glad I did.
We have some uncanny similarities: I am also a Jen (Jenn c/o my many Canadian friends!), a mother of two, a lifelong observer, an ex-kid who preferred the company of adults, a social chameleon, a melancholic, and an eccentric comedienne to most who know me.
My kids have about a decade on yours, and I tend to idealize their younger days in my nostalgia bank. They’re great young men, so I guess I’ve ‘succeeded’ as a mom… but they will embark on their own adult lives far too soon. That I mourn deeply.
What you’re going through sounds so very, very similar to my emotional rollercoaster when the kids were young. Your eloquent descriptions shake me into admitting that what I like to recall as endless maternal elation was mixed with occasional doses of searing pain.
All of the responses to your post clearly show not only how much people respect and care for you, but also how many of us identify intimately with your plight. I, too, remember wondering, why am I the only one going through this? Obviously, I was in good company and didn’t even know it. My happy-mask assured that no one discerned my angst, which prolonged my agony. Your soul-baring should help you heal quickly and efficiently.
There are many complex gradations along the sadness/ grief / depression spectrum, and I still haven’t even figured out where my exact ‘spot’ is. I have eschewed medication during my lowest lows, which I sometimes regret profoundly.
If you continue to wander through the darkness, I truly hope you will be bolder that I and take that exploratory step. Chemistry has done wonders for many I know and love…
‘
My deepest condolences on the loss of your beautiful dog. I have lost several over the years, and it is gutting.
Continue to focus on those half-sized people with their open palms; mine now tower over me, and I can’t tell you what I’d give for a rewind button. Think of all the time you have left to watch them blossom, and to blossom alongside them…
Thank you for your exquisite words…gifts to us all.
Jenn – I am listening to you. I am so sorry over the loss of your dog. I can not imagine what you are going through right now but you are in my thoughts and prayers. Keep your palms open because we are here for you.
P.S. If it’s any consolation, although I originally came here for the laughs, I do feel like I have found a kindred spirit in you. Happy, sad, mad, funny, poo talk or no poo talk, I will be reading!
*deep breath*
Heart-wrenching.
*hug*
You are such an awesome writer. Seriously.
Those little half sized people, they’re not only sponges but they are rubberbands, too. And they will soak it all in and learn, but they won’t be harmed, they will bounce back. Your tears will make them who they are meant to be once they are full sized. Your impact, both the happy and the sad, are critical to them.
March on…
I came over here to check you out because Alice mentioned you over at Finslippy. I wasn’t sure what I would find. I’m so glad that I followed that link. In three entries you’ve made me laugh, cry and wax introspective about love and God and things dear to my heart. I’ve only been here for ten minutes.
If it’s okay I think I’ll come back again.
I’m very sorry about your dog and your sadness. Holding out palms to you…
This is the first post of yours that I’ve read, and I’m moved to tears. I just wanted to tell you that every single thing you wrote — about writing and blogging and parenting and being — struck a chord with me. I’ll look forward to your poo posts (because, heck, poo is funny), but I hope you’ll always feel free to write what you feel.
I am sad too. I scare me too. I have searched and come up empty handed for longer than I care to reflect on. I worry that ‘my little half-my-size ones’ will only remember me being like ‘this’ when they’re grown. But I feel safe here, because you put into words what I cannot and I want to offer you my palms. And I accept the offering in yours. Thank you.
I was sad too. For close to 15 years I was sad. And it waits on the edges of my happiness, always looking for an opening. Always showing up a couple of times a month. I am not the mommy I should be. I am not the wigfe I should be. The writer. The woman.
But I am finally finding happy. From nowhere, I have become comfortable in my own skin. While sadness might be sleeping like a dog, always curled up by my feet, I am still finally happy.
Happiness will come. And eventually I will be that mommy I am in theory. And they’ll be as happy as I am. But we’re all getting there… one day at a time.
If we weren’t sad we wouldn’t recognise happiness.
Spring will come soon.
← Previous Comments