A kind soul left an apple tree on my porch. The porch that is now my porch and not our porch. It needed a tree, I think. It needed something.
The girls and I pull up in front of the house the other day to see spring branches spilling over the porch banister, reaching down the unmown hill for us, welcoming us out of our battered old car.
“What is THAT?” I say. It is not every day one’s porch grows a tree whilst one is gone.
“A tree!” the girls shriek in awe. “A TREE GREW ON OUR PORCH!”
David opens the door. He explains that a local acquaintance and blog reader brought by a big apple tree branch she’d cut down. She’d put it in a jelly jar for me. The effect is pretty darn charming.
Sophie asks, “Can we plant it in the garden? And have apples?”
Hattie jumps up and down, cheering. “APPLES APPLES APPLES!”
David and I try to explain that this particular flora is more in the realm of Christmas trees. Once cut, well, just enjoy it while you can. No apples, just green.
We all admire the budding branch in its jelly jar, propped against the blue wooden post of the porch.
“I like it,” I say. “It’s very odd.”
“So do I,” says Sophie. “It’s weird.”
“We’re weird. It’s a good thing, weird,” I say.
David and Hattie head inside with the hungry dogs. Sophie and I remain on the porch with the apple branch.
“It’s like a Christmas tree for spring,” I say. “We could decorate it, with lights.”
She nods.
“Yeah,” agrees Sophie. “Let’s.”
Another plan. Small steps.
*****
Yesterday David closed on his new place.
At dinnertime, he asks the girls if they want to head over to see the place, to have a Subway sandwich picnic on the floor.
“Could I go too?” I ask.
He waits, unsure of me.
“I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t completely dying of curiosity,” I say.
“Sure,” he acquiesces, after a pause. “I guess I can treat you to a Subway sandwich.” There is a wry smile.
The girls pack some toys to bring over to the new place—assorted houses and school buses and Polly Pockets that we tuck into the hatchback trunk with David’s art supplies.
We drive to Subway, passing a cable TV truck emblazoned with the tagline: CONNECTING YOU TO YOUR TOMORROW. I find a pen and write this on my hand. I write a lot of notes on my left hand these days.
Our sandwich artists are very accommodating. Cucumbers there? Nope, no cucumbers on that one, lots of black olives, no onions, strawberry milk, sorry, no, chocolate, what? Yes, chips instead of cookies. Kids! So unexpected!
“All together?” asks the cashier, finally.
“Yup,” I say. “All together.” I am shy, saying this.
David pulls out his wallet and pays, and we are on our way. Much more quiet than our usual “on our way”s. There have been so many of these. The phrase will mean something different now. For now, we ignore this.
He’s close by, in a big building, a condo unit as opposite aesthetically from our old house as our girls are opposites.
“Well,” he says, fishing out the new keys. “This is it.”
He lets us in to the main building. We each take a daughter by the hand and up the stairs to his unit. I am still breathing, and I note this with some mild interest. I do not expect to still be breathing at this point. Breathing is good, I think.
Then he opens the door. I stop breathing, recover, stop breathing, recover. Breathing and not breathing and recovering is also preferable to not breathing, so. Small steps.
“Wow,” I say. Talking is also preferable to not talking, I figure. Or it’s not. There is no way to know, in the moment.
The girls burst into the unit, which is big and airy and furniture-less. They swarm it like bees, seeming like far more than two little girls as they spread out, exploring.
“Wow,” I say again. So this is how it will be.
“I know,” says David.
The four of us spread out a tablecloth and set out our Subway picnic on the floor. We eat. We talk. We laugh. We are quiet. We ooh and we aah over all the cool stuff in Daddy’s new place. We drink our milk, we share our chips.
“Are you crying yet, Mommy?” asks Sophie. “You looked like you had your crying face about to start.”
“Not yet,” I say. “Probably soon.”
I am right on that. Soon.
I do not mean to present this as the happiest family picnic of all time. This is not that, but it is not the saddest family picnic of all time, either. I cry, I sniffle. David’s eyes turn red. Still, we pass Subway napkins back and forth, discuss the wood floors together, confer about his potential options for furniture placement. There have been worse days, somehow, still.
I know why and I don’t know why we are here. Our stories do not match up. This is the most difficult part. But to me there is the sense that this is supposed to be happening, that we are where we need to be. But there is also the sense that we have not yet begun to process the hundreds of tiny, stinging paper-cut griefs that will be part of our days for a long time to come. We are fearful, of course. We smell fear, mistrust, in the other, but we are doing our best to reach out to each other anyway. We were never cruel to each other, and the thought of starting now is appalling.
We do our best to explain the upcoming schedules to the girls, to say it will be difficult, and weird sometimes, but also pretty cool to have two neat places to call home.
“It’s a new chapter,” David says. “New chapter, same characters.”
I like this. “Exactly. The same characters,” I agree. “Now check out the bathroom. I don’t think you’re going to be complaining about taking baths together over here.”
The girls abandon chips and tear into the bathroom. I know what they are seeing. My reaction was similar.
“OH MY GOSH! OH! MY! GOSH! WE HIT THE JACKPOT!” they howl as they climb into the big big tub.
Back on the tablecloth, David and I smile wanly at each other.
“If I come over here to water your plants, I am totally taking a bath,” I say. “You can’t begrudge me that.”
He nods, smiles.
I like to think we are normalizing this, by sharing a meal here all together, by showing that all the characters are still accounted for. That it is okay to be excited in front of Mommy about the blue room where there will soon be bunkbeds. That it is okay to laugh at Sophie singing her homemade arias as she echoes her way through the maze of Daddy’s new walls. The Labrador Retriever who lives above the unit does not think Sophie’s impromptu arias are okay, not yet. He is making this clear, whining and barking through the ducts as if Chihuahua puppies are being tortured downstairs. The girls laugh harder, discuss befriending the Lab soon with biscuits and pats.
It’s not everyone’s way, but it works for us. So far. I have no idea if it will continue to work. But this week, this is as right as it gets, for this, for us in this. I am humbled daily by this experience—by the absence now of past sureties, of certainties, of boundaries. The tears come and go and come again all day long, for reasons beyond which I could begin to explain. There is too much to explain, too many stories, too many versions, too many layers, too much lost. Best to save our breath. For breathing.
We are flying blind now. I am leaning too forward into the wind, sticking my neck out, stupidly—gasping, panicked. David is leaning well back, averting his head to the side, to be sure he can breathe as needed—fearful, wary. But it’s the same wind blowing. I take some small comfort in that.
As we walk back to the car and note how pretty the skyline looks at dusk, Sophie takes my hand and David’s and swings between us. She crows, “Another sensational family moment!”
Again, I look down at her. I have to know.
“Wait, are you being serious?”
“Yes,” she says, simply. “Yes.”

{ 42 comments… read them below or add one }
Small steps, one step at a time. Living in the moment is where you need to be and you are, all of you. God speaks in the wind and in the silence. Keep listening.
Keep breathing, it will get easier. I know it. We all sometimes forget how to breathe, you know? You are going to be OK. I don’t know you, but I just know that it’s true.
This brought tears to my eyes and an ache to my heart. I think that you are strength to the girls and they are strength to you. And, keep looking for those little signs, like a gifted apple tree, that things will be ok.
That kid is a pip.
Actually, I think the whole non-traditional-feeling-your-way- what-the-hell-are-we-doing family thing is pretty great. And I love that she sees that, because it means you are doing something right in these moments.
You make me cry with your honesty, and the bravery you are showing, whether it is real or masterful acting, is awesome. And to have your child name that as another sensational family moment says it all. Those girls have special parents, that’s for sure. I pray for you four, and the real-life people who love you.
It sounds so hard and so poignant and so awful and so hopeful. Sending you my best thoughts that the sad parts will come less frequently and the sensational family moments will still happen here and there.
oh honey you are killing me here…..
its going to be ok..it really really is
my god, you are all so amazing.
God, you break my heart and I don’t even know you. All my strength for you now. I can’t imagine being strong enough to do what you are doing, but I suppose no can until they are.
Yes, yes, what they all said. Keep breathing. LIsten to your gut.
When I try to explain bravery to my son, I tell him that bravery often involves small moments and tears. In reading your story, I know this is right.
I am bawling. Seriously bawling at my desk at work. Sniffling and blubbering and have no idea how to pull it together. I don’t know the whole story, but this part – I know that you are doing such a great job at not having your divorce hurt your children.
You were brave to go there and have that picnic. So very brave.
I’ve been through this and it’s tragic, and you’re right, you’re enduring the hardest part this very moment. But you will be happier someday. You wouldn’t be doing this if you didn’t know that with every ounce of your gut. Keep that in mind.
Such beautiful writing here. Truly.
You are doing such a wonderful job. Just keep holding on. It’s painful and it’s hard but you guys can keep doing it. My parent’s divorce was terrible and you are handling it sooo well. I don’t know you but I feel so connected to you. If I could I would keep your heart safe in my hands so it would never be broken…
I keep you and yours in my prayers. Take comfort in knowing that there are still people out there that care dearly for you and you’ve never seen their faces…
je-s-u-s. sorry to offend. i just had to catch my breath.
i don’t know how you’re able to articulate this experience, this blind trip towards the mysterious but it’s fascinating and breath-taking
i really admire your guts, girl. i’m trying to make similarly brave choices and am throwing up inside but it’s great to be able to hear what you’re going though
Hi there,
I stopped reading blogs a while back, and just got back to my regular routine. I was surprised and saddened to read what you’ve been going through, wish there was something this complete stranger who lives far far away could do.
Try planting that apple branch, apple trees are amazing things (did you know you can graft a branch from a completely different tree onto a tree and it’ll grow?) and it just might surprise you by growing.
you have a way with words. so beautiful, yet so heartbreaking.
I admire you for your strength, even if you don’t feel it in the moment.
Wow, you have SUCH a gift for writing, and being able to connect with what you’re feeling and put it into words…that will help you get through it. Don’t worry about this becoming a “divorce blog”; it ‘s a blog about your life, what you’re going through right now. Some of can relate because we’ve been through it, others pray they never experience it. Either way, sharing your experience is a gift.
I’ve commented before that my ex and I have a very friendly relationship; it IS possible, as long as you both put the childen first. It’s not always easy, but it is possible and it is so worth it.
You’re on your way.
I really dig what you said about the wind.
I have friends who split up and did the opposite of what you’re doing, marinating in bitterness and hate. It was painful to watch. Not that there isn’t pain in any chosen course, it is divorce after all, but still. I admire the way you and David are choosing to navigate through the unfamiliar waters.
This going to sound tasteless I know, but this true story would be a best seller, not so much because of the story, but because of who and how it is being told.
Just for the record, I want to know what happened. Not that it’s any of it is my business or to point to fingers, but I think it would help me (maybe others) to understand how you can end up eating a Subway picnic on your soon to be ex’s hardwood floors. How is there is money for a jacuzzi and hardwood floors? How do you go from tearing up rugs and scraping kitchen cabinets and wishing for a Cranberry Red front door – to jacuzzi’s and hardwood floors?
I want to know what event was so profound to cause the seemingly perfect couple (or least one half of it, if my reading between the lines is close) to throw in the towel so quickly and completely? Its like going for a snack during a movie and when you return everyone saying “Shhhhh” when ask “What did I miss?”
What happened to canoe boy from that first date?
Heartbreaking. Yet…hopeful.
My parents divorced when I was 12. Last week, at family gathering, there was a moment when everyone else was elsewhere and my parents, brother, and I were sitting on the couch together, chatting peacefully.
Even now, two decades later, I still feel that tug of the “original” family. You’re giving your daughters a gift by being kind and caring to each other.
Your writing leaves me breathless and trying so hard not to sob at my desk. Thank you for continuing to share your journey.
Anon, anon! Questions, so many, but a fake email address! I share what I can, and I will always love that canoe boy.
I am so sorry. I hate that you are going through this. It sounds too painful.
Your writing is amazing, I could see what you were describing so well. I cried with you.
My parents separated when I was 15 (in 1990) and divorced in 1991. It was not amicable. It is not amicable. But it is better now.
They were my own parents, I watched it unfold, I heard things said that I never wanted to know,
but I still don’t know what really happened.
From 33, I think that no one but the couple themselves can know what really happened- and sometimes even they may never really know.
The oldest child, I got stuck in the middle of my parents, and then stuck between each parent and my younger sister- the go between, the word taxi.
I went through the years of screaming and sobbing and name calling and hurtful questions flung at one another through me and asked again and again- questions I could not answer or hated to answer.
I went through that but never exactly knew what was lost until last Thansgiving.
Last Thanksgiving I traveled with my boyfriend to visit his aunt and uncle where my family vacationed summer after summer as a family when I was a child.
I had not been there with my family since 1989.
When we got to her house, dropped our bags, showered, relaxed and walked down to the dock- all the sights and smells hit me in the gut and I remembered.
I remembered how it felt to be there as a family, I remembered what kind of a family we had once been, and I cried.
After the divorce, my rightfully angry mom told me horrible things about my father over and over year after year, and I wondered why she was so upset about the divorce if she had been so miserable and my memory of my childhood became discolored and marred.
But in South Carolina on the dock on Thanksgiving Day, I remembered what a very nice little family we had once and how much fun we used to have together once and I realized how lucky I truly had been.
I admit I’m with anon (but posting as my crazy self, ballsy or stupid, you choose lol!)- I can imagine that for many of us, we don’t even begin to understand how point A became point B for you guys. I don’t say this with cruelty or prying, just an honest to goodness inability to understand such unhappiness springing from such happiness, and marring the lives of such kind people.
I admire your ability to go through this tenderly and without malice- so few lack that quality. So few can choose gentleness over blame and anger- seeing those rare qualities in both of you is part of what makes this all so difficult to comprehend.
This made me tear up.
Sad but poignant.
This post is so raw and honest…..I have said it before, but I admire you and David so much for the way you are still kind to each other.
You brought tears to my eyes, because even though I am sure you know you have made the right decision, the reality of it must be very hard when it comes.
Hugs to you….
I admire your willingness to take this as it comes. Husband and I are about to begin a trial separation, and I am elated and terrified and grieving and rejoicing all at once. Your situation is an inspiration to me (not that that is the slightest damn bit of comfort to you when your heart is breaking, but there it is). You are only human, as are we all, but your strength is beyond the ordinary.
I didnt know… (I skipped your earlier posts and dove right into the last one, and it sounded like all was much the same, sort of), but then here you write “my porch” and “his new house”… and, what can I say, we’re on the same ride, just different theme parks (mine’s in español). Right now I’m sad and confused and angry and still in love, and all I can do is watch myself fall apart when I’m alone. i also do a lot of pretend fun and smiles, though my daughter has seen me cry too. And there’s so much in my head, and then nothing at all but being tired. I dont know how to fix this, how to fix me, not yet. BUT, I still think/feel I made the right decision, for myself and Catalina (and him as well). We’re going to be fine. and so are you. Jazz hands!!!!
I haven’t been here in a while.
It broke my heart…
I prefer to think of an unusable email address – I’ve experienced the horrors of non-anonymity on the web.
I say I want to know, but more in the rhetorical sense (post #20) – I want to know, but I don’t want you to really tell me, I know it’s not my business.
I’ve been through it and know the urge must be great to want to throw virtual pots and pans and jars of spaghetti sauce. Your restraint is amazing.
There are many firsts coming your way that are going to fell like a punch in the gut. I wish you all the best in these times.
*feel*
Oh, you all take my breath away. I agree with Sophie, these are truly “sensational family moments.” Yes, there’s sadness in them, but I’m continuously blown away by the hope that’s lurking there, just under the surface. You and David have given and continue to give your girls such extraordinary gifts. Keep breathing- you are doing this, and doing it well.
What you articulate so well is the knowing and the not knowing – the fear and the almost shameful peace, the breathing and the not breathing that any of us that have gone through a divorce (a family scramble? a role reassignment?) experienced.
The people I connect with most are those that write exactly the way they think and talk… and that’s you. Real, genuine, broken, learning, breathing.. not breathing.
Stay strong, girl…
You know, you and David continue to impress me with how you’re handling yourselves. Even in the face of divorce, you’re very respectful, at least as far as I can tell from what you’ve written here. That’s not to say that you don’t hurt, but you’re not taking your hurt out on each other. The world could take their cues from you.
I share anons curiosity about the whys and hows. Is it wrong for me to want YOU to have the jacuzzi and hardwood floors (or at least the cranberry door)? Not that I wish anything bad for David. I thank you for sharing in startling honesty as much as you do, and I respect your privacy. But I still wonder…
Please. Never. Stop. Writing
So real, so poignant, so funny, so painful. You knocked this one out of the park, hon.
Love to you & yours.
Okay, I just started reading some book by some blogger who writes funny stories about her family and four children. Compared to your writing, Jenn, this book could not be more vanilla. I don’t get it. Why not put all this into a book of essays?
You write beautifully. Hang in there.
Oh, Jenn. This is so agonizing, and beautiful. And agonizing.
Thinking of you and hoping — no, knowing — that it will all be OK in time. It will, it has to be.
you move my heart. no. honestly. my heart shifts around in my chest while I read your tales of life and how best to live it, how best for you to live it. (there is no other way, loveliest of creatures.)
and thank you (which sounds trite as trite can be) — thank you, three-dimensionally, for doing what you can to give those of us reading the gift of your honest, truly lived existence. you shine.
you shine.
You gave me a taste of what that must be like to be going through that. It sounds unreal, like it couldn’t be happening. But is.